Jonathan Kay
Quillette, Sept. 2, 2022
“Canadian media is now full of earnest denunciations of an idea that MacKenzie describes as having been “jokingly created during a livestream.”
Last month, Pierre Poilievre, the populist front-runner in the race to become leader of Canada’s federal Conservative party, was photographed shaking hands with Jeremy MacKenzie, a former soldier facing weapons and harassment charges. MacKenzie is an odd duck who combines a penchant for extremist right-wing rhetoric with a predilection for ironic Internet memes. But almost no one in Canada knew his name until that now infamous handshake. As for Poilievre, he says he didn’t recognize MacKenzie, or form any particular memory of having met him—a claim that even progressive journalists have admitted is entirely credible.
“My campaign events are public,” Poilievre told the media once the impromptu meeting between the two men was reported. “There is no registration and anyone can walk in. In fact, over the course of my campaign I have shaken hands with literally tens of thousands of people at public rallies. It is impossible to do a background check on every single person who attends my events. As I always have, I denounce racism and anyone who spreads it. I didn’t and don’t know or recognize this particular individual.”
In a normal country, in a normal time, this would pretty much have been the end of things. But as I’ve written elsewhere, Canada’s intellectual class has, for several years now, been passing through a period of social panic on the issue of right-wing extremism. And it doesn’t take much—in this case, a mere handshake was enough—to elicit accusations that the federal Conservatives are conspiring with (or at least encouraging) outright fascists and white supremacists. In this case, the smoking gun was taken to be the fact that Poilievre denounced MacKenzie’s racism without actually “disavowing” him by name. The leader of the left-wing New Democratic Party, Jagmeet Singh (who himself has spent periods of his political career seeking to appease Air India conspiracy theorists), asserted that this lapse meant Poilievre was “wink[ing] at white supremacy.”
One publication seized on the incident as proof that Poilievre is locked in a “dangerous dance.” Following a script that would be repeated by other outlets, the article used a daisy chain of ideological linkages to extrapolate from MacKenzie, to Canada’s “dangerous community of anti-government agitators,” until eventually getting to “the Atomwaffen Division, which the Southern Poverty Law Centre describes as ‘a series of terror cells that work toward civilizational collapse.’” Thus were readers rocketed, in the space of just three paragraphs, from a conservative politician shaking hands with a meme-spreading crackpot to the takeover of Ottawa by Nazi storm-troopers and the literal disintegration of Canadian society. … Source